naturejobs

Nature 412, 4-5 (5 July 2001) |

Special ReportScience shops provide non-profit alternative

Alexander Hellemans1

  1. Alexander Hellemans is a science writer based in Naples.

For comments, or story ideas, please contact Naturejobs at naturejobseditor@naturedc.com

After years of decline, non-profit consultancies science shops are starting to reinvent themselves, says Alexander Hellemans.

In 1972, a group of idealistic chemistry students at Utrecht University banded together to help anti-capitalist countries. They set up one of the first 'science shops', with the aim of helping non-profit clients solve problems. One of their early projects involved developing disinfectants to help the Vietcong fight disease. Much of the impetus behind that project was antipathy towards American involvement in Vietnam.

Unfortunately we are unable to provide accessible alternative text for this. If you require assistance to access this image, or to obtain a text description, please contact npg@nature.com

J. J. SMIT

Expanding horizons: science shops, such as the physics shop run by Frits van den Berg in Groningen, are starting to forge international links.

"The approach then was 'We will improve the world'," says Caspar de Bok, project coordinator of the biology science shop in Utrecht. "Subsequently, the idealistic character of these projects has subsided. Now we have several professional organizations that are well embedded in the universities in the Netherlands."

Since then, science shops have more or less shed their countercultural roots, banding together and expanding their reach. Their projects are less militant and more practical areas explored include noise pollution, environmental problems and health risks such as the possible effects of electromagnetic radiation from radio transmitters. The transformation and expansion of these services could mean jobs for people interested in research with social, rather than commercial or purely academic implications (see "Jobs on the shop floor").

Science shops emerged in the 1970s, in part as a response to 'for-profit' science. They were organized to bring science to those who either cannot afford to pay for research, or who would not be able to interest the research community in their questions. In the 1980s and 1990s the science-shop concept spread throughout Western Europe and to Israel, South Africa and Romania. But during the past decade the activity of science shops has slowed. Over the past five years, three science shops have been closed in the Netherlands and they have disappeared entirely from France and Belgium.

Top

GETTING ORGANIZED

But the concept is now showing signs of a comeback. A consortium of European science shops and the US equivalent, community research centres, are creating a professional organization, the International Science Shop Network (see ISSNET proposals). The organization could help bring together disparate shops, raise their profile and give them a greater voice in issues of science and society at a time when science's role in society is increasingly being questioned.

Unfortunately we are unable to provide accessible alternative text for this. If you require assistance to access this image, or to obtain a text description, please contact npg@nature.com

Shopkeepers: Utrecht's Caspar de Bok (top) and Bonn's Norbert Steinhaus.

Individual science shops have a history of working together. For example, members of the seven science shops in Utrecht are already linked to form a small network. "Because we are so small, the Utrecht network is very helpful," says Patricia Huisman, coordinator of the physics shop in Utrecht, adding that a larger international network would be invaluable.

Much of the backing for the international network is coming from the European Commission in Brussels, which funded a set of projects that investigated how an international network of science shops could be set up.

"Ultimately we hope that with a strong network of science shops we can better serve the needs of social organizations for research, and to give the public better access to scientific research," says de Bok. A database connected to a website will allow members to find out which science shop already has experience in a certain area. The network will also aim to direct efforts into countries where there are still no science shops.

Although the proposal will have to compete for funding, the European Commission is now actively encouraging the formation of a new network for science shops. "The importance of the relationship between science and society is higher than ever, and the scientific community cannot stay isolated," says Rainer Gerold, director of science and society at the European Commission.

An international network will help the local science shops avoid isolation, but it may also have an influence on science itself. "We can re-evaluate what we expect from science is the success of science only dependent on the production of research papers, or should we change the kind of incentive structures to produce research that benefits communities?" says Nicole Farkas, a graduate student at the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute in Troy, New York, who spent a year studying science shops in the Netherlands.

Unfortunately we are unable to provide accessible alternative text for this. If you require assistance to access this image, or to obtain a text description, please contact npg@nature.com

Conscientious work: science shops offer research projects with a social dimesion.

Top

MANY MODELS

Farkas notes that there is no one model for shops even in one country. The Dutch science shops are largely viewed as service providers for non-paying 'clients'. But some Dutch shops do take on projects for payment, whereas others are strictly non-profit.

Shops vary even more widely between countries. In the Netherlands, science shops are mainly funded by universities, of which they are a part. That is not the case in Germany. "Some of our projects are funded by the government, but also by the European Union," says Norbert Steinhaus who directs the science shop in Bonn. "We are working with foundations, we are working with the city of Bonn." Dutch science shops do their own research, whereas the Northern Ireland Science Shop functions as an intermediary, linking community groups to researchers at the universities, says Eileen Martin at the Belfast-based shop.

It is perhaps in the United States where the diversity is the widest. Many community research centres are associated with universities, but the majority are non-profit organizations and non-governmental, says Jill Chopyak, who is the executive director of the Loka Institute in Amherst, Massachusetts.

This diversity of approaches to setting up science shops will ideally be reflected in an international science shops network. Having such a repository will allow prospective shopkeepers to choose the model that works best for their community which is where the shops emerged from in the first place.

General Secretariat Dutch Science Shops right arrow http://www.ssc.unimaas.nl/LSW/indexuk.htm

The Loka Institute right arrow http://www.loka.org/

ISSNET right arrow http://www.bio.uu.nl/living-knowledge/confinfo1.html